WaukeshaNOW.com
search all things local
     
Blog Home |  Email Author  |        Welcome to MyCommunityNOW - Blogs Sign in | Join

Brookfield Basics

A column about history, culture, policy, and things in between.

Out of Balance - Sports and Forensics in Brookfield

By Tom Gehl
Thursday, Jan 31 2008, 08:51 AM

I have the day off and spent the morning enjoying small things, like taking our daughter to school, saying hello to her Principal and teachers, and an unhurried cup of coffee while reading the printed version of Brookfield Now.  Later, I have a lunch date with our third-grade son.  I will cherish this, as it could well be the last year he views Dad coming to school as something cool. 

Now before I get into the subject matter of this article, I have some disclaimers. 

I love sports - always have.  I love them as a participant and as a spectator, and was fortunate enough to have a solid, if not spectacular athletic experience in High School.  I remain as physically active as my schedule allows, and coach youth sports every other year.  Our kids enjoy their sports teams, and I state the obvious by recognizing athletics can be an integral part of a young person's physical, psychological, and emotional development.  

But I was struck by something while reading NOW that indicates we are out of balance.    

On page sixteen there is a brief (less than one hundred words) article noting the fact that the Brookfield East High School Forensics Team will be performing at the Elm Grove Public Library, on Thursday February 7th, at 7 PM.  I am glad that the editors of Brookfield Now highlighted this noteworthy event.

But later, beginning on page thirty, we are treated to six full pages of coverage for local sports and athletics, replete with four large pictures, two of which are in color.

I don't begrudge the coverage on sports.  But it is a commentary when the reigning Wisconsin State Champions in Forensics merit a photo-less blurb, compared to what our sports obsessed culture serves up for athletics.  

As mentioned earlier, last year the Spartan Forensics team brought home the State Championship Trophy.  Compare the coverage that team got with what we see when a local sports team plays a regular season game, much less wins a State Title. 

I have seen several students of BOTH High School Forensics Teams speak in public, and comport themselves with dignity and articulation.  These programs instill skills and attitudes in the kids that will last a lifetime, long after muscle and bone and reflexes are unable to do what they once did.

This isn't a criticism of Brookfield NOW, for it only serves what the market wants.

But maybe it's time we start giving some equal time to such achievements, and in so doing, getting back into balance.

Comments

My Two Cents   

Thanks for pointing out this incongruity, Tom.  Certainly our students in other areas of achievement deserve the same recognition as our athletes.  Forensic meets don't get the same "fan appreciation" as sports, but they certainly require many hours of prep and practice. These dedicated students deserve equal recognition. I hope the BrookfieldNow staff will pick up the torch.

January 31, 2008 2:52 PM

BrkfldDad   

Way to hit this one on the head Tom!  I wholeheartedly agree.  Perhaps it's a byproduct of what seems to be a majority of the baby boom generations' need to live vicariously through their children, the childhood they didn't have.  It's sure a lot more fun to live it as sports, rather than forensics.

January 31, 2008 3:53 PM

Larry Knetzger   

Hi Tom , what a great commentary. It just seems like athletics is always over emphasized when looking through my eyes. I do believe those students that seem to do well in forensics usually to not have the athletic skills needed to enjoy that area of education. This is one of the reasons I will be interested in seeing how and why the gyms are being expanded in the referendum . Forensic skills will last a lifetime, athletic skills have the ability to shorten ones life through injury etc. Athletic interest is also good for the rest of your life and the need for exercise. The right balance would be great to see. Just a really great item brought to light by you. Thanks

January 31, 2008 5:28 PM

Shawn Matson   

Tom, thank you for your incite.  I have to agree that the focus is usually on sports.  My Two Cents is right--Forensics doesn't get as much fan appreciation as others.

February 1, 2008 2:56 AM

Mary Wacker   

Thanks for shining some light on Forensics - I am certainly biased, but I would love to see our hard working team at Brookfield East receive some public recognition for their remarkable successes.  We've already embarked upon our 2008 season with great results - a second place finish at Appleton East HS last Saturday (in a field of 30 schools), with lots of individual finalists.  Hope to have lots more great news to share throughout our season, as I am sure will our forensics teams from Brookfield Central and the two middle schools.  Our school district has a rich culture of excellence in speech and debate, and I'm not sure everyone knows that!  It's a reason for Elmbrook to be proud!

I'm a sports fan too, and I think there is room to celebrate all of our students in their extracurricular successes!  We'd be happy to share photos and results on a regular basis, and would welcome some attention from the sports page staff.

February 1, 2008 11:23 AM

Kyle Prast   

Excellent points one and all! Of all the things learned in school, theater, debate, music, art, etc. are all things you can continue in and enjoy for the rest of your life. Yet these subjects, in terms of school budgets, facilities, and press coverage always seem to get the short end of the stick. It is a shame. I would be happy to post pictures if Brookfieldnow doesn't. (My disclaimer: I'm not into sports but have worked in the arts.)

February 2, 2008 8:57 AM

GerryG   

Having no less than three cable channels at its disposal, one would think that the school district itself would lend a hand in boosting interest in Forensics by televising the team in action. Ms. Wacker would make a great color commentator and help in explaining nuances of the competition to viewers.

It would appear that you yourself could leverage that Tom.

February 2, 2008 3:27 PM

Leave a Comment

Please Sign In to post comment.

Posts

Your browser must support javascript to use the posts pager. Please enable javascript or return to the home page to page through posts.
Newer Older

Tags

No tags have been created or used yet.

Search the Blogs